What's your favorite song from every musical you've seen? Okay, that could be a VERY long list for some, so feel free to cut it off at your top 20 or something.

Aida - "Written In the Stars"
Altar Boyz - "I Believe"
Avenue Q - "I Wish I Could Go Back to College"
Beauty and the Beast - "Beauty and the Beast"
Big River - "Leavin's Not the Only Way to Go"
Blood Brothers "Tell Me It's Not True"
Bye Bye Birdie - "A Lot of Livin' to Do"
Cabaret - "Don't Tell Mama"
Chitty Chitty Bang Bang - "Hushabye Mountain"
Fame - "Bring On Tomorrow"
The Fantasticks - "Try to Remember"
Fiddler on the Roof - "Sunrise, Sunset"
Grease - "We Go Together"
Guys & Dolls - "Sit Down, You're Rockin' the Boat"
Hairspray - "You Can't Stop the Beat"
Into the Woods - "No One is Alone"
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat - "Close Every Door"
The King & I - "Getting to Know You"
Les Miserables - "Stars"
The Lion King - "He Lives in You"
Little Shop of Horrors - "Suddenly Seymour"
Mame - "Open a New Window"
Mamma Mia! - "The Winner Takes it All"
Mary Poppins - "Feed the Birds"
Next to Normal - "A Light in the Dark"
Oklahoma! - "Oh, What a Beautiful Morning"
The Phantom of the Opera - "The Music of the Night"
Ragtime - "Make Them Hear You"
Rent - "Goodbye Love"
The Sound of Music - "Climb Ev'ry Mountain"
Titanic - "We'll Meet Tomorrow"
Spring Awakening - "Touch Me"
Sweeney Todd - "Johanna"
West Side Story - "Tonight"
Wicked - "For Good"

The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee - The I Love You Song
Aida - Elaborate Lives
Aladdin - Arabian Nights
Anastasia - Once Upon a December
Annie - We'd Like To Thank You Herbert Hoover
Annie Get Your Gun - They Say It's Wonderful
Anyone Can Whistle - Everybody Says Don't
Anything Goes - I Get a Kick Out of You
Aspects of Love - Seeing is Believing
Assassins - Another National Anthem
Avenue Q - There's a Fine, Fine Line
Barnum - There is a Sucker Born Ev'ry Minute
Beauty and the Beast - If I Can't Love Her
Billy Elliot - Electricity
Cabaret - Maybe This Time
La Cage aux Folles - I am What I am
Camelot - If Ever I Would Leave You
Candide - Glitter and Be Gay
Carousel - Soliloquy
Cats - The Jellicle Ball
Chess - Nobody's Side
Chicago - Cell Block Tango
A Chorus Line - At the Ballet
City of Angels - Double Talk (Stine)
The Civil War - By the Sword / Sons of Dixie
Company - Getting Married Today
Dracula - Zu Ende
Evita - Goodnight and Thank You
Fame - The Teacher's Argument
Follies - The Road You Didn't Take
The Frogs - Instructions to the Audience
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum - Comedy Tonight
Grand Hotel - Love Can't Happen
Grease - There are Worse Things I Could Do
Guys and Dolls - Rockin' the Boat
Gypsy - Everything's Coming Up Roses
Hairspray - Nicest Kids In Town
I Love My Wife - Love Revolution
I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change! - Tear Jerk
Into the Woods - Your Fault
Jekyll and Hyde - Dangerous Game
Jesus Christ Superstar - Gethsemane
The King and I - Puzzlement
Kiss Me, Kate - Too Darn Hot
Kiss of the Spider Woman - Kiss of the Spider Woman
Kristina från Duvemåla - Du Måste Finnas
The Last Five Years - Climbing Up-Hill
Legally Blonde - Legally Blonde
The Life - People Magazine
The Lion King - Endless Night
The Little Mermaid - Her Voice
A Little Night Music - A Weekend In the Country
Love Never Dies - 'Till I Hear You Sing
Mame - Open a New Window
Mamma Mia! - The Winner Takes it All
Man of La Mancha - Man of La Mancha
Martin Guerre - I Will Make You Proud
Merrily We Roll Along - Good Thing Going
Les Misérables - One Day More
Miss Saigon - The Morning of the Dragon
Mulan - I'll Make a Man Out of You
My Fair Lady - Hymn to Him
Nine - Overture Delle Donde
Notre-Dame de Paris - Belle
Oklahoma! - Oh, What a Beautiful Morning
Oliver! - Where is Love?
On a Clear Day You Can See Forever - What Did I Have That I Don't Have?
On the Twentieth Century - On the Twentieth Century
Pacific Overtures - Please, Hello!
Parade - Old Red Hills of Home
Passion - Is This What You Call Love?
Phantom - Home
The Phantom of the Opera - Prima Donna
The Pirate Queen - I'll Be There
Rent - Seasons of Love
Saturday Night - Saturday Night
The Scarlet Pimpernel - Into the Fire
Show Boat - Ol' Man River
Song and Dance - Unexpected Song
Songs for a New World - I'm Not Afraid of Anything
The Sound of Music - No Way to Stop it
South Pacific - You Have to Be Carefully Taught
Starlight Express - There's Me
Sunday In the Park With George - We Do Not Belong Together
Sunset Boulevard - Too Much In Love to Care
Sweeney Todd - The Final Ballad of Sweeney Todd
Tarzan - Two Worlds
They're Playing Our Song - They're Playing Our Song
Titanic - To the Lifeboats / We'll Meet Tomorrow
We Will Rock You - Bohemian Rhapsody
West Side Story - Tonight (Quintet)
Which Witch - 2.665.866.746.664 Little Devils
Wicked - No One Mourns the Wicked
The Wild Party - Life at the Party
The Wizard of Oz - Over the Rainbow
You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown - Happiness
[title of show] - Die, Vampire, Die!

I just browsed through all of my Cast Albums, I have more, but I won't bother posting such a long list now.

Aida - "I Know the Truth"
Avenue Q - "A Fine, Fine Line"
Beauty and the Beast - "A Change in Me"
Bye Bye Birdie - "How Lovely to Be a Woman"
Cabaret - "Maybe This Time"
The Fantasticks - "They Were You"
Fiddler on the Roof - "Sunrise, Sunset"
Grease - "Summer Nights"
Guys & Dolls - "If I Were a Bell"
Hairspray - "Mama, I'm a Big Girl Now"
Into the Woods - "No One is Alone"
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat - "Any Dream Will Do"
The King & I - "We Kiss in a Shadow"
Les Miserables - "I Dreamed a Dream"
The Lion King - "Can You Feel the Love Tonight"
Little Shop of Horrors - "Suddenly Seymour"
Mame - "We Need a Little Christmas"
Mamma Mia! - "Thank You For the Music"
Mary Poppins - "Feed the Birds"
Next to Normal - "Wish I Were Here"
Oklahoma! - "Out of My Dreams"
The Phantom of the Opera - "The Point of No Return"
Ragtime - "Your Daddy's Son"
Rent - "Take Me or Leave Me"
The Sound of Music - "Sixteen Going on Seventeen"
Spring Awakening - "Touch Me"
Sweeney Todd - "Johanna"
West Side Story - "Quintet"
Wicked - "Thank Goodness"

Cabaret - Don't Tell Mama
Cats - Mungojerrie and Rumpleteazer
Chicago - I Know a Girl
Dracula - (the ones with Lucy's suitors)
Elisabeth - Frau Wolfs Salon
Evita - Peron's Latest Flame
Hair - Easy to be Hard
Into The Woods - Hello, Little Girl
Jesus Christ Superstar - This Jesus Must Die
Joseph...Dreamcoat - Potiphar
Keating! - Freaky
King and I - Whistle a Happy Tune
A Little Night Music - Weekend in the Country
Little Shop of Horrors - Feed Me
My Fair Lady - Just You Wait
The Producers - When You Got It, Flaunt It
Rent - We're OK
Rocky Horror - Time Warp
Spamalot - Diva's Lament
Starlight Express - Wide Smile
Sweeney Todd - A Little Priest
Tanz Der Vampire - Der Tanz Der Vampire
Tommy - Acid Queen
The Wiz - The Wiz
Young Frankenstein - He Vas My Boyfriend

Allegro - So Far
Annie - Easy Street
Annie Get Your Gun - What Comes Natur'lly
Anyone Can Whistle - A Parade in Town
Anything Goes - Anything Goes
Applause - Backstage Babble
The Apple Tree - Eden Prelude
Assassins - How I Saved Roosevelt
Avenue Q - For Now
Baby - What Could Be Better?
Bare - Are You There?
Barnum - Come Follow the Band
Beauty and the Beast - Be Our Guest
Big River - Muddy Water
Billy Elliot - Once We Were Kings
The Boys from Syracuse - This Can't Be Love
Brigadoon - Come to Me, Bend to Me
Bye Bye Birdie - Spanish Rose
Cabaret - Tomorrow Belongs to Me
Camelot - C'est Moi
Can-Can - I Love Paris
Candide - Overture
Carmelina - One More Walk Around the Garden
Carousel - Carousel Waltz
A Catered Affair - Prelude (this is the fourth instrumental piece I've put down, lol)
Chess - Anthem
Chicago - Razzle Dazzle
City of Angels - You're Nothing Without Me
Company - Being Alive
Curtains - I Miss the Music
Dear World - And I Was Beautiful
December Songs - Please Let's Not Even Say Hello
The Drowsy Chaperone - As We Stumble Along
Elegies - Mister Choi and Madame G.
Evening Primrose - If You Can Find Me, I'm Here
Evita - Buenos Aires
Fiddler on the Roof - Do You Love Me?
Finian's Rainbow - Look to the Rainbow
Fiorello! - When Did I Fall in Love?
Floyd Collins - Riddle Song
Follies - Losing My Mind
The Frogs - The Frogs
A Funny Thing Happened On the Way to the Forum - Comedy Tonight
Gigi - I Remember It Well
Godspell - All for the Best
Grand Hotel - Love Can't Happen
Greenwillow - The Music of Home
Grey Gardens - Will You?
Guys and Dolls - Sit Down, You're Rocking the Boat
Gypsy - Rose's Turn
Hairspray - It Takes Two
Hello, Dolly! - Hello, Dolly!
High Spirits - If I Gave You
How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying - Brotherhood of Man
In the Heights - Carnaval del Barrio
Into the Woods - No More
Jersey Boys - Fallen Angel
The King and I - Hello Young Lovers
King David - Psalm 8
Kismet - Stranger in Paradise
Kiss Me, Kate - So in Love
Kwamina - The Sun is Beginning to Crow
Les Miserables - Stars
Li'l Abner - If I Had My Druthers
The Light in the Piazza - Statues and Stories
The Lion King - King of Pride Rock
Little Fish - Revelations
The Little Mermaid - Kiss the Girl
A Little Night Music - Later
Mack and Mabel - Look What Happened to Mabel
Mame - My Best Girl
Man of La Mancha - The Impossible Dream
A Man of No Importance - The Streets of Dublin
Marie Christine - There's a Way Back to Paradise
Mary Poppins - Feed the Birds
Meet Me in St. Louis - The Trolley Song
Merrily We Roll Along - Good Thing Going
The Music Man - My White Knight
My Fair Lady - I've Grown Accustomed to Her Face
My Favorite Year - Twenty Million People
The Mystery of Edwin Drood - Moonfall
Myths and Hymns - Migratory V
A New Brain - Heart and Music
Next to Normal - I'm Alive
Nine - Grand Canal
Oklahoma! - Oh, What a Beautiful Mornin'
Oliver! - Consider Yourself
On a Clear Day You Can See Forever - On a Clear Day You Can See Forever
On the Town - New York, New York
Once on This Island - Mama Will Provide
Once Upon a Mattress - Song of Love
Pacific Overtures - Someone in a Tree
Paint Your Wagon - They Call the Wind Maria
The Pajama Game - Hey There
Pal Joey - Zip
Parade - The Old Red Hills of Home
Passion - Loving You
Peter Pan - Never Never Land
Peter Pan (Bernstein) - Who Am I?
The Phantom of the Opera - The Point of No Return
Phantom - My True Love
Ragtime - Journey On
Rent - Tango: Maureen
Rex - As Once I Loved You
Road Show - The Best Thing That Has Ever Happened
The Scarlet Pimpernel - Into the Fire
The Secret Garden - Lily's Eyes
Seussical - Alone in the Universe
She Loves Me - Dear Friend
Shenandoah - Meditation
Show Boat - Ol' Man River
Silk Stockings - Paris Loves Lovers
Song of Norway - Strange Music
The Sound of Music - Edelweiss
South Pacific - This Nearly Was Mine
Spamalot - The Song That Goes Like This
Sunday in the Park with George - Finishing the Hat
Sweeney Todd - Pretty Women/Epiphany/A Little Priest
Thoroughly Modern Millie - Muqin
Titanic - Finale
[title of show] - Nine People's Favorite Things
Two by Two - I Do Not Know a Day I Did Not Love You
West Side Story - Tonight (Quintet)
Wonderful Town - Swing!
You're a Good Man Charlie Brown - The Book Report
110 in the Shade - Everything Beautiful Happens at Night
1776 - He Plays the Violin
The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee - The "I Love You" Song

Whew.

hm, you cant have more than one song from every musical I guess?
Well:

Cats: Mungojerrie and Rumpleteazer.
Grease: Summernights
Kristina: Du måste finnas (Youll have to be there).
Phantom: Music off the Night.
Singing in the Rain: Singing in the Rain.
West Side Story: America.
JCS: Getshemane (well Ive seen the video^^)
We Will Rock You: Radio Ga Ga.
Romeo and Juliet: Help Yourself (Hjälp dig själv)
Mamma Mia!: Mamma Mia.
Sugar: Jag gör allt för Sandy.

Preatty short list so far...

Jesus Christ Superstar- Heaven On Their Minds
Cabaret- I Don't Care Much
A Funny Thing Happened On The Way To The Forum- Free
West Side Story- Tonight
The Phantom Of The Opera- Prima Donna
The Lion King- Shadow Land
Annie Get Your Gun- They Say Falling In Love Is Wonderful
Beauty And The Beast- Home
Little Shop Of Horrors- Skid Row
Grease- There Are Worse Things I Could Do
Les Miserables- One Day More
Tick Tick Boom- Therapy
We Will Rock You- Who Wants To Live Forever
Notre-Dame de Paris- Belle or La Monture

Annie : I Don't Need Anything But You
Les Belles-Soeurs : Crisse de Johnny
Cats : The Rum Tum Tugger
Fiddler on the Roof : If I Were a Rich Man
Godspell : Turn Back, O Man
Gypsy : Rose's Turn
Hair : Hair
Hairspray : I Know Where I've Been
In the Heights : Finale
Jesus Christ Superstar : Gethsemane
Mamma Mia! : Voulez-Vous
Mary Poppins : Let's Go Fly A Kite
Les Misérables : Noir ou Blanc
Next to Normal : I Am The One (Reprise)
Notre-Dame-de-Paris : Lune
The Phantom of the Opera : The Music of the Night
Rent : Your Eyes
The Sound of Music : Sixteen Going on Seventeen
Starmania : Le Blues du Businessman
Sweeney Todd : Epiphany
West Side Story : Something's Coming
Wicked : As Long as You're Mine[/i]

Secret Garden-Wick
Drowsy Chaperone- As We Stumble Along
Avenue Q- Fine Fine Line
Little Shop of Horrors- Meek Shall Inherit
Cats- Gus the Theater Cat
Hairspray- You're Timeless to Me
Into the Woods- Hello Little Girl
Company- You Could Drive a Person Crazy
Sweeney Todd- By the Sea
Oliver- It's a Fine Life
Spelling Bee- The I Love You Song
Rent- Out Tonight
You're a Good Man Charlie Brown- The Kite
Romance/Romance- It's Not Too Late
Once Upon a Mattress- Happily Ever After
Bye Bye Birdie- Telephone Hour
Grease- There are Worse Things I Could Do
Annie- I Don't Need Anything But You
King and I- Something Wonderful
Sunday in the Park with George- It's Hot Up Here
Oklahoma- Many a New Day
Gypsy- You'll Never Get Away From Me

A Little More Homework - 13
The "I Love You" Song - The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
There's a Fine, Fine Line - Avenue Q
If I Can't Love Her - Beauty and the Beast
Muddy Water - Big River
Electricity - Billy Elliot
Tell Me It's Not True - Blood Brothers
If I Were a Rich Man - Fiddler on the Roof
Summer Nights - Grease
God Save the People - Godspell
Let the Sun Shine In - Hair
I Know Where I've Been - Hairspray
Finale - In the Heights
No One is Alone - Into the Woods
Prologue: You Are What You Feel - Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
One Day More - Les Miserables
Be Prepared - The Lion King
If Only - The Little Mermaid
Our Last Summer - Mamma Mia!
Just Another Day - Next to Normal
My Husband Makes Movies - Nine
Oklahoma! - Oh, What a Beautiful Mornin'
Reviewing the Situation - Oliver!
Forever Yours - Once on this Island
Opening for a Princess - Once Upon a Mattress
Never, Neverland - Peter Pan
All I Ask of You (Reprise) - The Phantom of the Opera
What You Own - Rent
Lily's Eyes - The Secret Garden
Alone in the Universe - Seuessical
Climb Ev'ry Mountain - The Sound of Music
This is like choosing one of my own children. I just can't - Sweeney Todd
Everything That I Am - Tarzan
Tonight (Quintet) - West Side Story
No One Mourns the Wicked - Wicked
The Merry Old Land of Oz - The Wizard of Oz (RSC)
Happiness - You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown

I am glad the site is back up. Here is my list

Les Miserables: "On My Own."
Miss Saigon: "I'd Give My Life For You."
Lion King: "Shadowland."
Mamma Mia: "Slipping Through My Fingers,"Voulez-Vous," "Lay All Your Love On Me"(I can't decide).
Chess: "Nobody's Side."

I'll add more as I think of them.

The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee - The I Love You Song
Aida - I know the Truth
Aladdin - a whole new world
Anything Goes - It's DeLovely
Avenue Q - If you're gay
Beauty and the Beast - Home
Cabaret - Maybe This Time
Camelot - Before I gaze at you again
Carousel - If I Loved You
Chess - Heaven Help my Heart
Chicago - Cell Block Tango
A Chorus Line - Nothing
Company - Ladies who Lunch
Grease - Sandra Dee
Guys and Dolls - I'll Know
Gypsy - Some People
Hairspray - I Can Hear the Bells
Jekyll and Hyde - A new Life
The King and I - Something Wonderful
Kiss Me, Kate - I Hate Men (story of my life)
The Last Five Years - Summer in Ohio
The Lion King - Shadowland
The Little Mermaid - Part of that world
Mamma Mia! - Honey Honey
Les Misérables - A little fall of rain
Miss Saigon - I believe
Mulan - I'll Make a Man Out of You
My Fair Lady - wouldn't it be loverly
Nine - my husband makes movies
Oklahoma! - many a new day
Oliver! - Where is Love?
The Phantom of the Opera - Wishing you were somehow here again
The Pirate Queen - Woman
Rent - Over the Moon
Song and Dance - Unexpected Song
Songs for a New World - Stars and the moon
Sweeney Todd - Worst Pies in London
Tarzan - Two Worlds
West Side Story - The Jet song
Wicked - Defying Gravity
You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown - Beethoven Day