hes a clever little man, but im not a fan.

APART FROM obviously the masterpiece which is the phantom of the opera.

i think ALW musicals have an element of immaturity and simplicity to them which i dont enjoy...songs are predictable and lack of harmonies makes them dull i feel!

sorry to be negative. ill end on bigging him up

phantom of the opera rules? lol best i can do

he does right some good shows, but the simplism is somewhat boring. it annoys me how he has hold of most big theatres when there are alot better shows just waiting to come in! its ridiculous! lots of his shows have the same tunes within them and its just tedious. but hes not happy with all his 'hits' hes still tryin to do more. like 'the woman in white' ... what a febal attempt at a smash hit. there isnt one note in that show that wasnt taken from one of his others... he's got the hit, he should leave it at that.
but yes, phantom is amazing, as is JCS and several others... but its over now, he should leave it at that.

Who are you people? This is a CATS forum. This thread belongs in the ALW forum.

"These people" do have something of a point, though.

thanks...

pounce you are really really really rude.

i guess we should have expected a "catty" response in the CATS forum

thanks flitterbug

i agree with Pounce. Fine you have your opinion, i have no problem with that. But why have you come into a Cats forum full of Cats fans and told us you think Cats is "immature" "simple" "predictable" "lacking in harmony" and "dull"?
Like i said you're entitled to your own opinion but this isn't the place for this kind of post. It sounds to me like you're trying to get an arguement.

oh no nothing like that at all and ill be happy to explain

im new. lol and forgot i was in a sub forum of cats for the ALW forum- i intended on posting it in the main bit.

obviously made a mistake- do apologise.
i just cant stand it when people are just blatantly rude u no? its not fair that one new person makes a mistake and they get shouted at for it by people like pounce.

just the sort of behaviour you'd expect from an Andrew LLoys Webber fan! (joking)

Hey Ms. Jellicle, Rumblepurr, and other moderators I sense a flame war ahead with this.

I think (not positive) that Pounce said that because (at least to me) it appeared that you and rockyrocks appeared out of no where to have a dig at Cats. You're new so you've not been around this forum and i'd never seen rockyrocks around before, so it kinda looked like you were here to troll. Maybe thats just how my sleepy state see's it.
I don't think Pounce sounded too rude, if the message had been along the lines of "OMFG!! WTF are you doing? This belongs somewhere else you idiot" that would have been rude, Pounce was simply stateing.
And we all make mistakes

Having a point doesn't justify a thread in the wrong forum. They are doing a general discussion of ALW musicals in a CATS forum. If they want to discuss the music of CATS alone or how it compares to the other ALW shows or even other musicals...ok.

But in general, it is very unwise to say negative things about CATS here!

nope not here to try and start an argument simply a mistake.
i wasnt taking a dig at cats on its own promise, although it does come under the ALW musicals i meant.

it was the "who are you people?" that disheartened me
im over it now guys- thank god- thought i wouldnt be able to get through this rough patch